| Platinum | Catanese Real Estate |
| Gold | Andrea Clark Elite Home and Land Realty |
| Silver | F.C. Tucker Emge Realtors |
| Bronze | Shea Fleck - Re/Max Revolution |
| Top Pick | Elite Home and Land Realty |
| Top Pick | Era First Advantage |
| Top Pick | Jane Crowley |
| Top Pick | Keller Williams Capital Realty |
| Top Pick | Key Associates Signature Realty of Evansville |
| Top Pick | Knight Realty LLC |