| Platinum | Space Monkey Records |
| Gold | Evansville Toys and Game |
| Silver | Atmosphere Collectibles |
| Bronze | The Gaming Guild |
| Top Pick | A B C Hobbycraft |
| Top Pick | Clever Bay Sports & Gaming |
| Top Pick | Secret Headquarters |
| Top Pick | The Hobby Den |
| Top Pick | The Subscription Comic Shop |
| Top Pick | Your Brothers Bookstore |