| Vote Voted! Voting | Azzip Pizza |
| Vote Voted! Voting | Bobes Pizza |
| Vote Voted! Voting | By The Slice Gourmet Pizzaria |
| Vote Voted! Voting | Casey's Dugout |
| Vote Voted! Voting | Casey's General Store |
| Vote Voted! Voting | Deerhead Pizza |
| Vote Voted! Voting | Di Maggio's |
| Vote Voted! Voting | Dontae's Highland Pizza |
| Vote Voted! Voting | Fat Boy's Pizza, Newburgh |
| Vote Voted! Voting | Kipplee's Restaurant |
| Vote Voted! Voting | Lombardi's New York Pizza and Wings |
| Vote Voted! Voting | Pangea Kitchen |
| Vote Voted! Voting | Pizza Depot |
| Vote Voted! Voting | Pizza Oven |
| Vote Voted! Voting | Pizza Revolution |
| Vote Voted! Voting | Rounders Pizza |
| Vote Voted! Voting | Rounders Too |
| Vote Voted! Voting | Spankeys Una Pizza |
| Vote Voted! Voting | Steve's Una Pizza |
| Vote Voted! Voting | Turoni's Forget-Me-Not |
| Vote Voted! Voting | Turoni's Pizzery and Brewery |
| Vote Voted! Voting | Turonis Newburgh |
| Vote Voted! Voting | Twisted Tomato |