| Platinum | Di Maggio's |
| Gold | Azzip Pizza |
| Gold | Steve's Una Pizza |
| Gold | Turoni's Pizzery and Brewery |
| Silver | Kipplee's Restaurant |
| Silver | Pangea Kitchen |
| Silver | Turoni's Forget-Me-Not |
| Bronze | Dontae's Highland Pizza |
| Top Pick | Turonis Newburgh |
| Top Pick | Twisted Tomato |