| Platinum | Mayse Farm Market |
| Gold | Fresh Thyme Market |
| Silver | Farm 57 |
| Bronze | Evansville Farmers Market |
| Top Pick | Boonville Farmers Market |
| Top Pick | Bud's Farm Market |
| Top Pick | Franklin Street Market |
| Top Pick | Goebel Farms |
| Top Pick | Market On Main |
| Top Pick | Reimann's Farm Market |