| Platinum | Nellies |
| Gold | Kite & Key Cafe on Franklin |
| Silver | Cross-Eyed Cricket |
| Silver | Frankie's Restaurant |
| Silver | Savannah's Cafe |
| Bronze | Roosters Den Newburgh |
| Top Pick | Comfort |
| Top Pick | Denny's |
| Top Pick | Hornet's Nest |
| Top Pick | Ricks 718 |
| Top Pick | The Diner By Mele's |
| Top Pick | The Fine Swine BBQ and Catering |