| Platinum | Liberty Federal Credit Union |
| Gold | First Federal Savings Bank |
| Silver | Heritage Federal Credit Union (Bell Oaks) |
| Bronze | Old National Bank |
| Top Pick | Banterra Bank |
| Top Pick | Evansville Federal Credit Union |
| Top Pick | Fifth Third Bank & ATM |
| Top Pick | German American Bank |
| Top Pick | Indiana Members Credit Union |
| Top Pick | United Fidelity Bank |