| Platinum | River City Coffee and Goods |
| Gold | Corkscrew Curiosities |
| Silver | Your Brothers Bookstore |
| Bronze | Rare Bird uncommon gifts |
| Top Pick | Award World Trophies &Gifts |
| Top Pick | Memo |
| Top Pick | Snow's Landscape & Nursery |
| Top Pick | Social Bird Boutique |
| Top Pick | The Bay House |
| Top Pick | The Newburgh Mercantile |