| Platinum | The Bay House |
| Gold | Pat Coslett's Simplicity Furniture |
| Silver | Seek & Find Consignments |
| Bronze | Dean Bosler's Furniture & Mattress Showroom |
| Top Pick | Gehlhausen |
| Top Pick | Kim's Furniture in Newburgh |
| Top Pick | Peoples Furniture & Mattress Outlet |
| Top Pick | Walker's Hometown Store |