| Platinum | Your Brothers Bookstore |
| Gold | The Vineyard |
| Silver | Barnes & Noble Booksellers |
| Bronze | Bluestocking Social |
| Top Pick | Book Nook |
| Top Pick | Comic Quest |
| Top Pick | Evansville Toys and Game |
| Top Pick | The Bead Angel |
| Top Pick | The Book Broker |
| Top Pick | The Subscription Comic Shop |