| Platinum | His N Hers Flea Market |
| Gold | Corkscrew Curiosities |
| Silver | Brinker's Jewelers |
| Bronze | Sassafrassy's |
| Top Pick | Evansville Estate Emporium |
| Top Pick | Knight's Collectibles |
| Top Pick | Salvage Candy |
| Top Pick | Seek & Find Consignments |
| Top Pick | The Confectionery |
| Top Pick | The Vintage Market |