| Platinum | Di Maggio's |
| Gold | Azzip Pizza |
| Gold | Turoni's Pizzery and Brewery |
| Silver | Pangea Kitchen |
| Bronze | Casey's Dugout |
| Top Pick | Deerhead Pizza |
| Top Pick | Franklin St. Pizza Factory |
| Top Pick | Parkway Pizza |
| Top Pick | Rounders Pizza |
| Top Pick | Turoni's Forget-Me-Not |