| Platinum | Hacienda Mexican Restaurant |
| Gold | El Charro Mexican Restaurant |
| Silver | La Campirana |
| Silver | Los Bravos Mexican Restaurant |
| Bronze | Fiesta Alcapulco |
| Top Pick | Casa Fiesta Mexican Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Chava's Mexican Grill |
| Top Pick | El Paisano |
| Top Pick | Riviera Mexican Grill |
| Top Pick | The Diner By Mele's |