| Platinum | Major Munch |
| Gold | The TIn Fish |
| Silver | Long John Silver's |
| Bronze | Froggy's Restaurant & Sports Bar |
| Top Pick | Cheddar's Scratch Kitchen |
| Top Pick | Drake's Evansville |
| Top Pick | Golden Corral Restaurants |
| Top Pick | Sam's Southern Eatery |
| Top Pick | St Phillip's Inn |
| Top Pick | The Wheel House |