| Platinum | Toys to Treasure |
| Gold | Evansville Toys and Game |
| Silver | Build-A-Bear Workshop |
| Silver | Tools 4 Teaching |
| Bronze | Miller's 5 & 10 |
| Top Pick | Atmosphere Collectibles |
| Top Pick | Comic Quest |
| Top Pick | Secret Headquarters |
| Top Pick | The Vineyard |
| Top Pick | Toys R Us |