| Platinum | Give a Dog a Bone |
| Gold | PetSmart |
| Silver | Pet Food Center |
| Bronze | It Takes A Village Canine Rescue |
| Bronze | Vanderburgh Humane Society |
| Top Pick | Pet Supplies Plus |
| Top Pick | Tri-State Vet & Pet Supply |
| Top Pick | Welcome Waggin Dog Bakery |
| Top Pick | Whitlyn Aquatics, LLC |
| Top Pick | Wild Birds Unlimited |