| Platinum | Crumbl Cookies - Evansville |
| Gold | Insomnia Cookies |
| Silver | Great American Cookies |
| Bronze | Piece of Cake |
| Top Pick | Be Happy Pie Company |
| Top Pick | Bea Sweet Treats |
| Top Pick | GaylaCake |
| Top Pick | Just Rennie's Catering |
| Top Pick | The Bluebird Bake Shoppe and Party LLC |
| Top Pick | The Granola Jar |