| Platinum | Hawg and Sauce |
| Gold | MISSION BBQ |
| Silver | Bandana's BBQ Evansville IN |
| Silver | The Fine Swine BBQ and Catering |
| Bronze | Hickory Pit Stop |
| Top Pick | Kenny's Smoke Shack BBQ |
| Top Pick | Marx Barbecue |
| Top Pick | Miller's Catering |
| Top Pick | Pappa Bear's Catering |
| Top Pick | Zia Smoke BBQ |