| Platinum | Discount Tire |
| Gold | Best-One Tire & Service |
| Silver | Reis Tire Sales |
| Bronze | Costco |
| Bronze | Full Throttle |
| Top Pick | Best One Tire & Service 24 Hour Emergency Service |
| Top Pick | Evansville Auto Repair |
| Top Pick | Quality Automotive & Tire |
| Top Pick | Raben Tire & Auto Service |
| Top Pick | Tornatta Tire East |