| Platinum | Larry's Automotive |
| Gold | Full Throttle |
| Silver | Quality Automotive & Tire |
| Bronze | Super Service Center |
| Top Pick | Barton Automotive |
| Top Pick | Carx |
| Top Pick | Chris' West Side Auto Service LLC |
| Top Pick | Evansville Auto Repair |
| Top Pick | Muenstermans |
| Top Pick | Thrifty Car Care |